- Focus and Scope
- Section Policies
- Peer Review Process
- Open Access Policy
- Copyright
- Conflict of Interest
- Correction and Retraction
- Ownership and Management Information
- Plagiarism Policy
- Electronic Filing
- Manuscript Type
- Post-Publication Discussion
- Authorship Criteria
- Allegation of Research Misconduct
- Publication Schedule
Focus and Scope
DEMOKRASI : Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan adalah wahana pendorong perkembangan ilmu politik dan pemerintahan melalui dokumentasi hasil-hasil penelitian serta kajian kritis terhadap berbagai konsep baru, fenomena, dan peristiwa dalam kehidupan politik dan pemerintahan di Indonesia. Adapun ruang lingkupnya terdiri dari beberapa kajian, antara lain:
- otonomi dan desentralisasi
- kebijakan public
- tata kelola pemerintahan
- kepemimpinan
- birokrasi
- politik
- partai dan pemilu
- dan kajian seputar politik dan pemerintahan lainnya.
Section Policies
Articles
Peer Review Process
Semua artikel yang dikirimkan ke Jurnal DEMOKRASI ini harus memenuhi fokus dan ruang lingkup (focus and scope), serta panduan penulisan yang telah ditetapkan dalam jurnal ini. Naskah yang menyimpang dari ketentuan di atas, akan dikembalikan secara langsung oleh editor. Tidak hanya itu, semua isi naskah harus bebas dari plagiasi, karenanya disarankan bagi penulis agar menggunakan softaware deteksi plagiarisme untuk melakukan pemeriksaan kesamaan (similarity) terlebih dahulu sebelum dikirimkan ke OJS. Setelah artikel masuk di OJS, maka editor akan mengecek tingkat similarity artikel dengan menggunakan perangkat Turnitin. Editor akan mempertimbangan tingkat similarity tersebut untuk keputusan apakah akan ditindak-lanjuti ke reviewer atau dikembalikan ke penulis. Jika editor memilih untuk memproses review terhadap artikel, maka artikel akan dikirimkan kepada reviewer dengan sistem Single Blind, yakni proses review dengan menghilangkan jejak penulis. Artinya, reviewer tidak bisa melihat nama penulis, dan penulis juga tidak mengetahui siapa reviewer artikelnya.
Open Access Policy
This journal provides immediate open access to its content on the principle that making research freely available to the public supports a greater global exchange of knowledge.
Copyright
DEMOKRASI : Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan adalah jurnal terbitan Fakultas Sosial dan Ilmu Politik Universitas Muhammadiyah Lampung. DEMOKRASI mengizinkan penulis untuk memegang hak cipta dan mempertahankan hak penerbitan
Conflict of Interest
DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan is committed to ensuring that all editorial and peer-review decisions are fair, objective, transparent, and free from inappropriate influence. All authors, reviewers, and editors are required to disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that may influence their judgment or responsibilities.
A conflict of interest may arise when personal, professional, financial, academic, institutional, or other relationships could reasonably be perceived as influencing the objectivity or integrity of the research, peer-review process, or editorial decision-making.
Authors
Authors are required to disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest at the time of manuscript submission. Potential conflicts may include, but are not limited to:
• financial relationships or funding that could influence the research;
• employment or professional affiliations;
• personal or family relationships;
• academic or professional competition;
• intellectual property interests, including patents;
• institutional relationships; or
• other relationships or circumstances that may affect the objectivity of the research or its interpretation.
If no conflict of interest exists, authors should state: Conflict of Interest: The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest related to the publication of this article. Authors are responsible for ensuring that all relevant conflicts of interest involving the co-authors are properly disclosed.
Reviewers
Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest before accepting an invitation to review a manuscript. Reviewers should decline the invitation if they:
• have a personal or professional relationship with one or more of the authors;
• have recently collaborated with the authors;
• work at the same institution as an author;
• have a direct academic or professional competition with the authors;
• have a financial or other interest related to the research; or
• believe that their relationship with the manuscript or its authors could affect their impartiality.
Reviewers must not use information obtained during the peer-review process for personal, professional, or financial benefit. If a conflict of interest becomes apparent after accepting a review assignment, the reviewer must immediately inform the Editorial Office and, where appropriate, withdraw from the review.
Editors and Editorial Team
Editors must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest that could influence their editorial judgment. An editor should not handle a manuscript when the editor:
• is an author or co-author of the manuscript;
• has a close personal or professional relationship with an author;
• has a significant academic or professional conflict with an author;
• has a financial interest related to the manuscript; or
• has another relationship that may compromise or appear to compromise impartiality.
In such circumstances, the manuscript will be assigned to another qualified editor who has no relevant conflict of interest. Editorial decisions must be based on the manuscript's scholarly quality, originality, relevance, methodological rigor, and compliance with the journal's publication standards, rather than on commercial, personal, institutional, or other competing interests.
Funding and Financial Interests
Authors must disclose sources of financial support for the research and any relevant financial interests that could influence the research or its interpretation. Funding information should be included in the manuscript where applicable.
Management of Conflicts of Interest
When a conflict of interest is disclosed, the Editor-in-Chief will assess its nature and determine appropriate measures to protect the integrity of the editorial and peer-review process. Possible actions include:
• assigning the manuscript to an alternative editor;
• assigning an alternative reviewer;
• requesting additional disclosure or clarification from the relevant individual;
• requiring a disclosure statement to be included in the published article; or
• taking other appropriate measures to ensure an impartial editorial decision.
Failure to disclose a significant conflict of interest may result in further investigation and appropriate editorial action in accordance with DEMOKRASI : Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan publication-ethics policies.
DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan treats conflict-of-interest disclosures confidentially and handles them in accordance with accepted standards of publication ethics. The journal follows recognized publication-ethics principles and may refer to the guidelines and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) when managing conflicts of interest
Correction and Retraction
Commitment to Accuracy and Publication Integrity
Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan is committed to maintaining the accuracy, transparency, and integrity of the scholarly record. The journal recognizes that correcting the scientific and scholarly literature is an essential responsibility of ethical publishing. When errors, inaccuracies, or concerns affecting a published article are identified, DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan will assess the matter carefully and take appropriate action in accordance with recognized publication ethics principles and the journal's editorial policies. Corrections and retractions will be handled fairly, transparently, and promptly, with due consideration given to the reliability of the published findings and the interests of readers, authors, researchers, and the wider scholarly community.
Corrections to Published Articles
A correction may be issued when an error is identified in a published article and the error requires formal amendment to ensure the accuracy or clarity of the scholarly record. Such errors may include incorrect author information, affiliations, acknowledgments, funding details, references, figures, tables, data presentation, or other content that does not substantially invalidate the article's principal findings or conclusions. Authors who identify an error in their published work are encouraged to notify the Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan editorial office as soon as possible. Readers, reviewers, and other stakeholders may also report suspected errors by providing a clear explanation and supporting evidence, where available.The editorial team will evaluate the nature and significance of the reported error and determine whether a correction is necessary. Where appropriate, the journal may consult the authors, reviewers, or independent subject-matter experts before reaching a decision. Any approved correction will clearly identify the affected article, describe the nature of the error, and explain the necessary amendment. The original article will remain accessible, with an appropriate link or notice connecting it to the correction, whenever practicable. Minor typographical or formatting errors that do not affect the meaning, interpretation, or reliability of the article may not require a formal correction notice. The decision to publish a correction will depend on the significance of the error and its potential impact on readers' understanding of the published work.
Retraction of Published Articles
Retraction is a formal mechanism used to correct the scholarly record when a published article is found to be unreliable or when serious ethical or publication concerns warrant its withdrawal from the accepted body of scholarly literature. Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan may consider retracting an article when there is clear evidence of significant problems that undermine its validity, integrity, or ethical acceptability. Grounds for retraction may include, but are not limited to:
• Evidence of fabrication or falsification of research data or results.
• Plagiarism or substantial unattributed use of another person's work.
• Serious errors in research design, methodology, analysis, or interpretation that invalidate the principal findings or conclusions.
• Duplicate or redundant publication that materially compromises the originality or integrity of the scholarly record.
• Unauthorized use of data, research materials, images, or other content.
• Serious violations of research ethics, including the absence of required ethical approval or informed consent where applicable.
• Manipulation of the peer-review or publication process.
• Undisclosed conflicts of interest or other forms of misconduct that materially compromise the credibility of the research.
• Other substantiated circumstances demonstrating that the article's findings or publication integrity cannot be relied upon.
Retraction will not be used merely because authors disagree with one another, because findings are controversial, or because subsequent research challenges an article's conclusions. The decision will be based on the available evidence, the seriousness of the concern, and the need to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.
Procedure for Correction and Retraction
When a potential need for correction or retraction is identified, Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan will undertake an appropriate editorial assessment. The procedure may include the following steps:
1. Receipt and preliminary assessment: The editorial team reviews the reported concern and determines whether further examination is warranted.
2. Evidence gathering: Relevant documents, research data, publication records, and other supporting materials may be examined. The journal may seek clarification from the authors or consult independent experts.
3. Author notification and response: The corresponding author and, where appropriate, other affected authors will normally be informed of the concern and given a reasonable opportunity to respond.
4. Consultation with relevant parties: When necessary, Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan may contact the authors' affiliated institutions, research ethics committees, funders, or other appropriate bodies to obtain additional information.
5. Editorial decision: Based on the available evidence, the journal will determine whether no further action, a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction is appropriate.
6. Publication of an editorial notice: Where corrective action is required, the journal will publish a clear and appropriately documented notice explaining the decision and its basis, subject to applicable confidentiality and legal requirements.
The journal will endeavor to complete these procedures in a timely manner while ensuring fairness, impartiality, and sufficient consideration of the evidence. If an investigation remains unresolved but credible concerns exist regarding the reliability of an article, Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan may publish an expression of concern pending further clarification.
Retraction Notices and Accessibility
A retraction notice will clearly identify the retracted article and explain the principal reasons for retraction. Where appropriate and legally permissible, the notice will identify whether the retraction was initiated by the authors, the journal, or another relevant party. The notice will be linked to the original publication to ensure that readers can readily understand the article's status. Retracted articles will generally remain accessible for the purpose of preserving the scholarly record, but they will be clearly marked as retracted in the article's online version and associated publication records, where technically practicable. The retraction notice will be published separately and linked to the original article. Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan will take reasonable steps to ensure that the article's retracted status is communicated clearly to readers and relevant indexing or archiving services, where applicable.
Responsibilities of Authors and Editors
Authors are responsible for ensuring the accuracy and integrity of their published work. If they discover a significant error or become aware of credible evidence that their article may be unreliable, they should promptly inform the editorial office and cooperate with the journal's assessment. Authors may request a correction or retraction and should provide a clear explanation and supporting documentation. Editors are responsible for evaluating reported concerns objectively and making decisions based on the available evidence, established publication ethics principles, and the journal's policies. Editorial decisions will not be influenced by an author's institutional affiliation, professional status, personal relationships, or the potential impact of a correction or retraction on the journal's reputation. If the authors disagree with a proposed correction or retraction, the journal will consider their explanations and relevant evidence before making a decision. Where a serious concern remains unresolved, Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan may proceed with an appropriate editorial notice based on the evidence available and the journal's ethical responsibilities.
Appeals and Dispute Resolution
Authors who believe that a correction or retraction decision was made on the basis of incomplete evidence, procedural irregularities, or a demonstrable error may submit a reasoned appeal to the editorial office. Appeals should identify the grounds for reconsideration and include relevant supporting information. The appeal will be reviewed impartially, and independent advice may be sought where appropriate.The submission of an appeal does not automatically suspend an editorial action when immediate clarification is necessary to protect the integrity of the scholarly record. Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan will communicate its decision and the principal reasons for it to the relevant parties.
Transparency, Confidentiality, and Ethical Considerations
Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan will handle correction and retraction cases with due regard for confidentiality, procedural fairness, and the rights of all parties involved. Information will be disclosed only as necessary to assess the concern, communicate an editorial decision, or meet applicable ethical and legal obligations. The journal will avoid making premature public judgments about alleged misconduct and will distinguish between confirmed findings, unresolved concerns, and allegations that have not been substantiated. All corrective actions will be proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the identified problem. The journal will seek to avoid unnecessary harm to authors while prioritizing the accuracy and reliability of the scholarly record.
Commitment to Maintaining the Scholarly Record
Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan considers correction and retraction essential safeguards for responsible scholarly publishing. By addressing errors transparently, investigating credible concerns, and issuing appropriate editorial notices, the journal seeks to maintain reader confidence, support research reproducibility, and uphold the principles of academic integrity. These procedures will be implemented consistently and responsibly, with reference to recognized publication ethics guidance, including applicable recommendations from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), where relevant. Through these measures, Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan reaffirms its commitment to ensuring that published research remains as accurate, transparent, and trustworthy as possible and that the scholarly record is corrected whenever reliable evidence demonstrates that corrective action is necessary.
Ownership and Management Information
DEMOKRASI : Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan is owned and managed by Prodi Ilmu Pemerintahan Universitas Muhammadiyah Lampung, Indonesia. The journal is managed by an editorial team consisting of the Editor-in-Chief, editors, and other editorial staff who are responsible for the academic and editorial management of the journal.
Publisher:
Fakultas Ilmu Social Dan Ilmu Politik Program Studi Ilmu Pemerintahan
Jalan: Prof. Dr. Hamka Sukarame Bandar Lampung
Email: Demokrasi.uml@gmail.com
Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan operates independently in its editorial decision-making. Editorial decisions are based on the scholarly quality, relevance, originality, and integrity of submitted manuscripts and are not influenced by commercial or other non-academic interests. The ownership and management of the journal are clearly disclosed to ensure transparency and accountability in the publication process
Plagiarism Policy
DEMOKRASI: editorial board recognises that plagiarism is not acceptable and therefore establishes the following policy stating specific actions (penalties) upon identification of plagiarism/similarities in articles submitted for publication in DEMOKRASI. DEMOKRASI will use Turnitin's originality checking software as the tool in detecting similarities of texts in article manuscripts and the final version of articles ready for publication. A maximum of 20% of similarities is allowed for the submitted papers. Should we find more than 20% of the similarity index, the article will be returned to the author for correction and resubmission.
Level of Plagiarism
Minor: A short section of another article is plagiarised without any significant data or idea taken from the other paper. Action: A warning is given to the authors and a request to change the text and properly cite the original article is made
Intermediate: A significant portion of a paper is plagiarised without proper citation to the original paper Action: The submitted article is rejected and the authors are forbidden to submit further articles for one year
Severe: A significant portion of a paper is plagiarised that involves reproducing original results or ideas presented in another publication Action: The paper is rejected and the authors are forbidden to submit further articles for five years.
It is understood that all authors are responsible for the content of their submitted paper as they all read and understand Lisensi Creative Commons Atribusi-BerbagiSerupa 4.0 Internasional If a penalty is imposed for plagiarism, all authors will be subject to the same penalty.
Electronic Filing
DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan implements an electronic filing and manuscript submission process to facilitate the efficient, transparent, and organized handling of scholarly manuscripts. The electronic submission system is designed to simplify communication between authors and the editorial team, support the management of submitted documents, and ensure that manuscripts can be processed systematically throughout the editorial and publication workflow.
DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan encourages authors to submit their manuscripts electronically in accordance with the journal's submission guidelines. Electronic filing enables authors to provide the required manuscript files, author information, supporting documents, and relevant declarations through the designated submission platform or official submission channel specified by the journal.
1. Electronic Submission of Manuscripts
Authors are required to prepare their manuscripts according to the journal's author guidelines before submitting them electronically. Manuscripts should be complete, clearly structured, and prepared in the required file format. Authors should ensure that the title, abstract, keywords, main text, references, tables, figures, and other necessary components are included as applicable to the manuscript type. During submission, authors must provide accurate information, including the manuscript title, author names, institutional affiliations, corresponding author's contact details, and other information requested by the submission system. The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that the submitted files are complete and that all information provided is accurate and consistent with the manuscript. Where required, authors should also submit supplementary materials, ethical approval statements, informed consent declarations, funding disclosures, conflict-of-interest statements, and other supporting documents relevant to the research.
2. File Preparation and Formatting
All submitted files must comply with the technical and formatting requirements established by DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan. Manuscripts should be prepared using an accepted word-processing format, such as Microsoft Word, unless otherwise specified in the journal's submission instructions. Authors should ensure that the document is readable, properly organized, and free from unnecessary formatting inconsistencies. Tables and figures should be clearly labeled, numbered consecutively, and accompanied by appropriate titles, captions, and source acknowledgments where applicable. If the journal applies a double-anonymous peer-review process, authors must prepare an anonymized manuscript that does not directly identify the authors or their institutions. Author details and other identifying information should be submitted separately through the designated fields or files. Authors should also remove identifying information from document properties and other file metadata where necessary.
3. Submission Confirmation and Initial Screening
Following electronic submission, authors should retain the submission confirmation or reference number provided by the journal, where available. This information may be used for future correspondence and inquiries regarding the status of the manuscript. The editorial team conducts an initial screening to assess whether the submission falls within the scope of DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan and complies with the journal's basic submission requirements. This screening may include checking manuscript completeness, formatting, originality, ethical declarations, and suitability for further editorial consideration. Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's requirements may be returned to the authors for correction or additional information before proceeding to the next stage. Submissions that are outside the journal's scope or fail to satisfy essential editorial or ethical requirements may be declined at this stage.
4. Editorial Processing and Peer Review
Manuscripts that pass the initial screening may be assigned to an editor for further assessment and, where appropriate, peer review. The electronic filing process supports the organized handling of manuscripts, reviewer reports, editorial decisions, and revised submissions. Authors may be requested to revise their manuscripts in response to editorial comments or reviewer recommendations. Revised manuscripts and accompanying response letters should be submitted through the designated electronic channel within the specified deadline, if one is provided. All communications concerning manuscript evaluation, revision requests, acceptance, or rejection should be handled through the journal's official communication channels. Authors are expected to respond professionally and provide clear explanations of how they have addressed editorial and reviewer feedback.
5. Communication with the Editorial Office
Electronic filing facilitates communication between authors and the DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan editorial office throughout the submission and review process. The corresponding author is responsible for monitoring official communications and ensuring that requests for additional information, document corrections, or manuscript revisions are addressed promptly. Authors should use the contact information or communication facilities provided by the journal when requesting clarification or assistance. Inquiries should include the manuscript title and submission reference number, where available, to help the editorial team identify the relevant submission. Authors must promptly inform the editorial office of any significant errors discovered after submission, changes to author information, or other circumstances that may affect the editorial evaluation of the manuscript.
6. Data Accuracy, Confidentiality, and Security
Authors are responsible for ensuring that all information and documents submitted electronically are accurate, complete, and appropriate for editorial assessment. Personal details, institutional affiliations, funding information, ethical declarations, and author contributions should be provided truthfully and consistently. DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan is expected to handle submitted manuscripts and associated materials confidentially and to restrict access to authorized individuals involved in the editorial and review process, in accordance with the journal's applicable policies and data protection requirements. Authors should not submit confidential information belonging to third parties without appropriate authorization. Research data, images, tables, and other materials included in the submission must be used in compliance with applicable ethical, legal, and copyright requirements.
7. Revised Manuscripts and Additional Documents
When revisions or supplementary documents are requested, authors should submit the required materials electronically according to the instructions provided by the editorial office. These materials may include a revised manuscript, a response to reviewers, updated figures or tables, additional ethical documentation, or corrected author declarations. Authors should clearly identify changes made to the manuscript and ensure that the revised version addresses the relevant editorial comments. Where requested, a point-by-point response should explain how each comment has been addressed or provide a reasoned explanation when a suggested change has not been adopted. Only the latest intended version of the manuscript should be identified as the version for further consideration. Authors should avoid submitting duplicate or conflicting versions that may cause confusion during editorial processing.
8. Technical Problems and Submission Assistance
If authors experience difficulties with the electronic submission system, encounter problems uploading files, or are unable to complete the filing process, they should contact the DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan editorial office through the official contact details provided on the journal's website. Authors should describe the technical issue clearly and provide the manuscript title, submission reference number if available, and relevant error information. If the electronic platform is temporarily unavailable, authors should follow the alternative submission instructions provided by the editorial office rather than sending multiple duplicate submissions. The journal aims to provide reasonable assistance to authors to support a smooth and accessible submission process.
9. Author Responsibility and Final Verification
Before completing an electronic submission, authors should verify that all required files have been uploaded successfully and that the information entered into the submission system is correct. The corresponding author must ensure that all co-authors have reviewed and approved the manuscript and agreed to its submission to DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan. Authors should also confirm that the manuscript is original, has not been published previously, and is not simultaneously under consideration by another journal, except where an explicitly permitted arrangement applies. All necessary permissions, acknowledgments, and declarations must be provided in accordance with the journal's policies. Submitting a manuscript electronically does not guarantee acceptance or publication. Every submission remains subject to the journal's editorial assessment, applicable peer-review procedures, ethical requirements, and final publication decision.
10. Commitment to an Efficient Submission Process
Through electronic filing, the DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan seeks to improve the efficiency, accessibility, and transparency of scholarly communication. The process is intended to support the timely handling of submissions, facilitate communication among authors and editors, and maintain appropriate records throughout the manuscript evaluation process. DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan encourages all authors to follow the established submission procedures and cooperate with the editorial team to ensure that manuscripts are processed accurately and efficiently. By promoting responsible electronic submission practices, the journal aims to uphold academic integrity, support a consistent editorial workflow, and contribute to the dissemination of high-quality research in commerce, management, tourism, and related disciplines.
Manuscript Type
The journal accepts the following types of manuscripts:
Original Research Article
Reports original empirical research based on quantitative, qualitative, or mixed-method approaches. The manuscript should present a clear research problem, appropriate methodology, findings, discussion, and conclusions that contribute to the development of knowledge and practice in education.
Review Article
Provides a critical and comprehensive synthesis of previously published research on a specific topic. Review articles may include systematic reviews, scoping reviews, or other rigorous literature review approaches and should identify research trends, gaps, and directions for future research.
Case Study Article
Presents an in-depth investigation of a particular educational case, institution, program, classroom, learning practice, or educational phenomenon. The study should provide sufficient contextual information and a systematic analysis of the case.
Conceptual/Theoretical Article
Discusses educational concepts, theories, models, frameworks, or perspectives based on a critical analysis of relevant literature. The manuscript should offer a clear conceptual contribution or provide new insights for educational research and practice.
General Requirements
All manuscripts must be original, have not been published previously, and must not be under consideration for publication in another journal. Manuscripts must fall within the scope of the journal and comply with the journal's author guidelines, ethical standards, and publication policies.
Post-Publication Discussion
Commitment to Scholarly Dialogue
DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan supports constructive post-publication discussion as an essential component of scholarly communication, research transparency, and the continuous development of scientific knowledge. The journal recognizes that the publication of an article does not necessarily conclude scholarly evaluation. Further discussion, critical assessment, and the exchange of evidence-based perspectives may contribute to clarifying findings, identifying limitations, and improving the reliability and impact of published research.
Scope of Post-Publication Discussion
Post-publication discussion may address the methodology, data interpretation, theoretical framework, research findings, conclusions, or practical implications of articles published in Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan. Submissions may include scholarly comments, critical observations, methodological clarifications, alternative interpretations, or other substantive contributions relevant to previously published work. All contributions must demonstrate academic relevance, provide a clear rationale, and be supported by appropriate evidence or scholarly references where necessary.
Submission and Editorial Assessment
Readers and researchers who wish to comment on an article published in Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan may submit their contributions to the editorial office through the journal's designated submission channels. Submissions should clearly identify the article under discussion and explain the specific issues, arguments, or findings being addressed. The editorial team will assess each submission for relevance, originality, academic quality, factual accuracy, and compliance with the journal's publication ethics policies. Where appropriate, submissions may undergo peer review or independent expert assessment. The journal reserves the right to request revisions or decline submissions that do not meet its scholarly and editorial standards.
Right of Response
To promote fairness, transparency, and balanced scholarly discussion, the authors of the original article may be invited to respond to substantive comments or criticisms. Any response should address the issues raised directly, provide supporting evidence where appropriate, and maintain a professional and respectful tone. The editorial team will determine the appropriate format and publication process for comments and responses, taking into account their academic merit and relevance to the published record.
Ethical Standards and Professional Conduct
All post-publication discussions must adhere to the principles of academic integrity, objectivity, respect, and responsible scholarly communication. Contributions should focus on the scientific or scholarly content of the work rather than personal characteristics or unsupported allegations against the authors. Authors of comments and responses are responsible for ensuring the accuracy of their statements, properly acknowledging sources, and disclosing any relevant conflicts of interest.
Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan does not accept defamatory, abusive, discriminatory, or deliberately misleading content. Concerns about possible research misconduct should be reported through the journal's established procedures for handling allegations of research misconduct rather than presented as unverified accusations in post-publication commentary.
Publication and Editorial Decisions
Accepted post-publication comments and responses may be published in an appropriate format, subject to the journal's editorial policies and publication procedures. Where applicable, the published discussion will include clear references and links to the original article to facilitate access and contextual understanding. Editorial decisions will be based on scholarly merit, relevance, evidence, and compliance with ethical standards, rather than on whether a contribution supports or challenges the conclusions of the original publication. If post-publication discussion identifies a substantive error or raises credible concerns regarding the reliability or integrity of a published article, Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan may conduct a further editorial assessment and take appropriate action. Such action may include requesting clarification from the authors, publishing a correction, issuing an expression of concern, or retracting the article when warranted by the available evidence and the journal's publication ethics policies.
Transparency and Preservation of the Scholarly Record
Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan is committed to maintaining a transparent, accurate, and accessible scholarly record. Post-publication discussions, author responses, and related editorial notices will be linked to the relevant publication whenever practicable. Any action affecting the status or interpretation of a published article will be communicated clearly and responsibly, in accordance with applicable publication ethics principles.
Commitment to Continuous Scholarly Improvement
Through post-publication discussion, Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan seeks to encourage critical thinking, intellectual exchange, methodological rigor, and continuous improvement in research and scholarly practice. The journal welcomes respectful, evidence-based contributions that advance understanding, clarify scientific claims, and strengthen confidence in the published literature. By facilitating responsible dialogue after publication, Governance: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan aims to foster an inclusive and constructive scholarly environment in which research can be examined, challenged, and refined for the benefit of the academic community and society.
Authorship Criteria
DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan stipulates that authorship must reflect a genuine intellectual contribution and responsibility for the published work. This policy applies to research articles, literature reviews, and conceptual articles.
Authorship Requirements
1. Every individual listed as an author must meet all of the following criteria: Make a substantive contribution to the formulation of ideas or research design, or to the collection, analysis, or interpretation of data. In review and conceptual articles, contributions may include the development of a conceptual framework, the selection and synthesis of literature, or the construction of a scientific argument.
2. Draft the manuscript or critically revise it to strengthen its intellectual substance.
3. Approve the final version of the manuscript for publication.
4. Be willing to take responsibility for all aspects of the work, including ensuring that any issues regarding the accuracy or integrity of any part are properly investigated and resolved.
All individuals who meet these four criteria must be listed as authors. Contributors who have made substantive contributions must have the opportunity to participate in the drafting or revision of the manuscript and the approval of the final version.
Non-Author Contributors
The provision of funding, a formal position, general supervision, administrative assistance, language editing, or technical assistance alone is not sufficient to qualify for authorship. Contributors who do not meet all authorship criteria may be listed in the Acknowledgments section, with a description of their contributions and their consent.
The status of an academic advisor, institutional head, or research team member does not automatically confer authorship. Authorship for articles derived from undergraduate theses, master’s theses, or doctoral dissertations must be determined based on each individual’s actual contributions.
Order of Authors and Corresponding Author
The order of authors’ names must be agreed upon by all authors prior to manuscript submission, based on contributions and mutual agreement. The corresponding author is responsible for:
1. Managing communication with the editor during submission, review, and publication.
2. Ensuring that all authors meet the authorship criteria and approve the manuscript, author order, and statement of contributions.
3. Ensuring the completeness of author information, affiliations, and documents requested by the journal.
4. Coordinating responses to inquiries regarding the article after publication. The designation of a corresponding author does not diminish the responsibilities of the other authors.
Changes to Authorship
Any addition, removal, or change in the order of authors after manuscript submission must be communicated to the editor with a clear rationale and the written consent of all authors, including those being added or removed. The editor will evaluate the request before approving any changes. Changes made after publication, if approved, must be documented through an official correction.
Prohibited Authorship Practices
DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan does not permit:
1. Gift or honorary authorship: listing an individual as an author out of respect, personal connection, or position without meeting the criteria for authorship.
2. Guest authorship: the inclusion of an individual to enhance reputation or publication opportunities without a contribution that meets the criteria.
3. Ghost authorship: the omission of an individual who meets the authorship criteria from the list of authors. Artificial intelligence tools, including generative AI, cannot be listed as authors because they cannot provide consent or assume responsibility for the work. Their use in manuscript preparation or the research process must be transparently disclosed in the relevant sections. Authors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of the entire manuscript.
Authorship Disputes
Authorship disputes must be resolved by the authors and, if necessary, the relevant institutions. Editors do not determine individual contributions in such disputes, but may request clarification and supporting evidence and may suspend the editorial process until the matter is resolved. The handling of alleged authorship violations follows the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
Allegation of Research Misconduct
Commitment to Research Integrity
DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan is committed to promoting responsible research practices, transparency, accountability, and trust in scholarly publishing. All allegations of research misconduct will be handled in a timely, impartial, and responsible manner, guided by recognized publication ethics principles and the journal's editorial policies.
Scope of Research Misconduct
Research misconduct may include, but is not limited to, fabrication or falsification of research data, plagiarism, inappropriate manipulation of images or research results, duplicate publication, undisclosed conflicts of interest, unethical research practices, and other forms of conduct that undermine the integrity, reliability, or originality of scholarly work. Allegations may concern manuscripts submitted for publication, articles under review, or papers already published in DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan.
Reporting Allegations
Authors, reviewers, editors, readers, and other stakeholders who have reasonable concerns about potential research misconduct are encouraged to report them to the DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan editorial office through the journal's official communication channels. Reports should include relevant details and supporting evidence, where available, to facilitate a fair and thorough assessment. All reports will be treated seriously, and the identity of the complainant will be handled confidentially to the extent reasonably possible.
Assessment and Investigation
Upon receiving an allegation, the editorial team will conduct a preliminary assessment to determine whether the concern warrants further investigation. Where appropriate, the journal may request clarification, supporting documentation, or a response from the authors concerned. Investigations will be conducted objectively and fairly, ensuring that all relevant parties have an appropriate opportunity to provide information.
When necessary, DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan may consult independent experts, contact the authors' affiliated institutions, or seek guidance from relevant research integrity bodies. The journal will not make a determination of misconduct solely on the basis of an unverified allegation. All decisions will be based on the available evidence and the principles of fairness, confidentiality, and due process.
Editorial Actions and Corrective Measures
If an allegation is substantiated, DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan will take appropriate action in accordance with the seriousness and nature of the misconduct and the journal's editorial policies. Possible actions may include requesting corrections, publishing an expression of concern, retracting a published article, rejecting a manuscript, or restricting future submissions where justified by the circumstances. Relevant institutions or other appropriate bodies may also be notified when necessary and appropriate. Any correction, expression of concern, or retraction will be communicated transparently through the journal's publication channels, with an explanation of the reasons for the action, while respecting applicable confidentiality and privacy requirements.
Confidentiality and Protection Against Retaliation
DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan will make reasonable efforts to protect the confidentiality of all parties involved in the assessment and investigation of allegations. Information will be disclosed only when necessary to investigate the concern, comply with applicable requirements, or implement appropriate editorial actions. The journal does not tolerate knowingly false, malicious, or deliberately misleading allegations. At the same time, individuals who raise concerns in good faith should not be subjected to retaliation or unfair treatment.
Appeals and Review
Authors or other affected parties may submit a reasoned appeal if they believe that an editorial decision concerning an allegation of research misconduct was based on incomplete information, procedural irregularities, or a demonstrable error in assessment. Appeals will be reviewed impartially, and additional information may be requested where necessary. The journal's final decision will be communicated to the relevant parties with an appropriate explanation.
Commitment to Ethical Publishing
DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan recognizes that maintaining research integrity is a shared responsibility among authors, editors, reviewers, institutions, and the wider scholarly community. The journal will continue to uphold ethical publishing standards, address concerns responsibly, and implement appropriate corrective measures to preserve the accuracy and credibility of the scholarly record.
Publication Schedule
DEMOKRASI: Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan is published twice a year (biannual publication), with regular publication scheduled as follows:
• Maret — Issue 1
• September — Issue 2
Manuscript submissions are accepted throughout the year. All manuscripts undergo initial editorial screening, peer review, and revision before the editor makes a final acceptance decision.
Accepted articles are published once peer review, required revisions, and final editing have been completed. Articles are published progressively within the current issue as they become ready for publication. Therefore, the publication date of each article depends on the completion of the editorial process rather than solely on its submission date.







